"I love your blog!
I'll keep reading as long as you keep blogging" - - - Rick

  • "I continue to enjoy your blog.
    It's excellent." -- Rodney Hide, Member of Parliament, and Leader of the ACT Party, New Zealand.


  • "I now live, breathe, and occasonally poo economics..." — former student

    For Upscale Clothing on-line,
    Visit www.Blaec.com


    Contact Information

    Facebook: John P. Palmer
    "We saw a lot of road kill and thought of you." —my sister

    Podcasts of My Intro Economics lectures
    (in .wma format)
    For my 2005 Radio Economics MP3 podcasts, go to the bottom of the page that lists the lecture podcasts.



    Canada


    United States


    Israel







Learn to become a successful trader in the stock market. Learn about bettertrades strategy here.


Getting a St louis payday loan is quick and easy. Get check payday loan from a trustworthy online company.

My Photo
Blog powered by TypePad

« Marginal Tax Rates, Welfare, and Work Effort | Main | How Small Investors Can Participate in Geithner's Plan »

March 25, 2009

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00e54ecbb69a883301156e53cf25970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Economics: the Dismal Science:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Stephen Gordon

Sandra Peart (who went to grad school with me) and David Levy have a surprising take on this:

**************************

Everyone knows that economics is the dismal science. And almost everyone knows that it was given this description by Thomas Carlyle, who was inspired to coin the phrase by T. R. Malthus's gloomy prediction that population would always grow faster than food, dooming mankind to unending poverty and hardship.

While this story is well-known, it is also wrong, so wrong that it is hard to imagine a story that is farther from the truth. At the most trivial level, Carlyle's target was not Malthus, but economists such as John Stuart Mill, who argued that it was institutions, not race, that explained why some nations were rich and others poor. Carlyle attacked Mill, not for supporting Malthus's predictions about the dire consequences of population growth, but for supporting the emancipation of slaves. It was this fact—that economics assumed that people were basically all the same, and thus all entitled to liberty—that led Carlyle to label economics "the dismal science."

******************

More here:

http://www.econlib.org/library/Columns/LevyPeartdismal.html

Kinda makes you wonder why 'dismal' is considered to be an epithet...

EclectEcon

Stephen,
Thanks for the comment, but Wikipaedia puts it the other way wrt Mill. Here's the rest of their entry, which I truncated because I didn't want to detract from Ironman's message, which was why I made the posting:

"However the full phrase "dismal science" first occurs in Carlyle's 1849 tract entitled Occasional Discourse on the Negro Question, in which he was arguing for the reintroduction of slavery as a means to regulate the labor market in the West Indies:

"Not a 'gay science,' I should say, like some we have heard of; no, a dreary, desolate and, indeed, quite abject and distressing one; what we might call, by way of eminence, the dismal science"

Developing a deliberately paradoxical position, Carlyle argued that slavery was actually morally superior to the market forces of supply and demand promoted by economists, since, in his view, the freeing up of the labor market by the liberation of slaves had actually led to a moral and economic decline in the lives of the former slaves themselves.

Carlyle's view was attacked by John Stuart Mill and other liberal economists."

According to this, it was Mill who attacked Carlyle.

The comments to this entry are closed.

  • Economists are Gods --- J.B.

    "Palmer's is one of my absolute favorite econ blogs." -- Ian


    Note: I do not necessarily endorse any of the products advertised on this site.

    I love your blog! It is the first one I read every day -- Eric F.
    C'est la vie.
    C'est la guerre.
    C'est la pomme de terre.


    Always an informative, interesting and sometimes even amusing read! —BBS

    Click here to order from Amazon.ca



    "I really enjoy your site, and I'm planning to assign your blog to my students. I love to find "real world" examples to supplement the text, and your blog is terrific for that. Thanks for writing it!" -- J.A.B.
    eXTReMe Tracker
  • Blogroll



    Adloyada
    Aid Watchers (Bill Easterly)
    Anomaly UK
    Antitrust Hotch-Potch
    Aplia Econ Blog
    Asymmetric Information
    Atlantic Blog
    Professor Bainbridge
    The Becker-Posner Blog
    The Big Picture [B. Ritholtz]
    Blue-Blogging Soapbox
    Calculated Risk
    Captain Capitalism
    The Cato Blog
    The Corner [Nat'l Rev.]
    Coyote Blog
    The Custom House Ben Muse
    Brad DeLong
    Discarded Lies
    Division of Labour
    Daniel Drezner
    Economist's View Mark Thoma
    Economonitor at RGE Monitor
    Econopundit [Steve Antler]
    Effect Measure [Pub. Health]
    EU Referendum
    Execupundit
    David Friedman's Ideas
    The Gods of the Copybook
    Grandinite
    Stephen Hicks
    Rodney Hide,
          New Zealand MP
    Hispanic Pundit
    Houston's Clear Thinkers
    Joanne Jacobs
    Infectious Greed
    Knowledge Problem
    Kruse Kronicle
    Little Green Footballs
    Macroblog
    Michelle Malkin
    Ben Muse (econ, Alaska)
    New Virginia Churchman
    Normblog
    Off-Wing Opinion
    Organizations and Markets
    Out of Control (Reason)
    Outside the Beltway
    Overcoming Bias
    Overlawyerd
    phi beta cons
    Poor and Stupid
    Power Line
    Priv. Sector Dev. Blog
    Provocateur
    A Random Walk
    The Road Kill Diaries
    Nouriel Roubini
    Sabernomics
    Felix Salmon
    Roger Simon
    Sports Law Blog
    Stumbling & Mumbling
    TCS Daily
    Tiger Hawk
    Michael Totten
    The Volokh Conspiracy
    Wall Street Examiner
    Not Even Wrong
       Peter Woit on Astrophysics

    Ezra Levant's Website

    Economics Lecture Notes On-line