A couple of years ago, my older son [David Ricardo Palmer] and I did some blind taste tests of scotch, graciously organized and administered by Ms. Eclectic.
During that test, we were both able to identify LaPhroaig (a very smoky, peaty scotch) which is also my son's favourite. It turned out then that my preferred scotch was Lagavulin, which edged out Caol Ila. The results of that blind taste test confirmed my experience from visiting distilleries in Islay several years ago: I liked LaPhroaig, but preferred Caol Ila, and liked Lagavulin better than all the others.
On Christmas night, 2013, we repeated the taste testing, this time with these 11 different scotch whiskies I had accumulated over the past 6-7 months [again with the gracious assistance of Ms. Eclectic]:
They are not all from Islay, but they are all to one degree or another smoky and peaty-tasting scotches. From left-to-right:
- Laphroaig -- we used the 10 year-old, which I have always preferred to their quarter cask. But when we opened it the previous evening, we both had the sense that it was defective or something. It certainly didn't seem very smoky or peaty.
- Talisker. It is from the Isle of Skye, not from Islay, but it is well-regarded by many. It did reasonably well in our previous taste-test.
- Caol Ila. This is the largest distillery on the island of Islay. In previous blind tastings, I ranked it fairly high. I have always liked it.
- Ardbeg. Another distillery on Islay that produces an excellent scotch. It wasn't part of our previous taste testing, and my experience had been that I haven't quite liked it as much as I like some of the others.
- Highland Park. This not an Islay scotch. I had heard from several non-connoisseurs that it was decent but had never tried it until recently when I received a bottle as a gift. Sampling it a month ago led me to believe I wouldn't care for it.
- Ben Riach Curiositas. This scotch is brewed in Speyside. It is rare that a scotch from that region is peaty. I have no idea what prompted me to buy it.
- Lagavulin. My taste-testings, both social and blind, had always led me to prefer Lagavulin over the others. It is 16-years-old and is the most expensive of the lot that we tried.
- Islay Mist (8-year-old) is a very inexpensive blend of Islay scotches, with explicit mention that Laphroaig is one of the scotches in the blend. Its price of $30/bottle (vs $130/bottle for Lagavulin) has made it a popular scotch for me. I like it okay, but not as much as some of the others.
- Dun Bheagan. My son gave this to me for Christmas. Interestingly, the village of Dun Bheagan is in Skye, but this bottle explicitly says it is 10-year-old single malt from Caol Ila from Islay.
- Jura Prophecy. This is a very limited annual-production scotch from a distillery just across the channel from Islay. I have had other Jura scotches and not been excited by them; I was told this one is peatier and more special. My reaction when I sampled it last month was "eehhhhh".
- Islay Mist (17-year-old) is a pricey blend of Islay scotches. When I tried it last year, I rated it below the 8-year-old blend.
My son and I put numbers on the bottoms of 11 glasses each. Unfortunately we don't own 22 uniform glasses, and possibly the different shaped glasses may have affected our ratings.
Ms. Eclectic then numbered the bottles and poured small samples of each of the scotches for both of us:
We sat across the table from each other and as we tasted each scotch in turn, we made brief comments and slid the glass for that scotch out toward the middle of the table: the farther toward the middle, the more we liked the scotch.
To be clear, the scotches were not presented to us in the same order as the initial photo in this posting.
We took two full passes, tasting the scotches, commenting, etc. and adjusting our ratings as we went. After each sip/taste, we also drank some club soda to at least partially cleanse our palates.
Here was the array of glasses after our first pass. Mine are on the left, my son's are on the right:
After the first pass, my son had a slight preference for the fourth scotch and the eleventh scotch. I had a definite preference for the 7th scotch. Neither of us liked the second one (I left my glass for that one so far to the left it doesn't appear in the photo).
After and during the second pass, we made some minor adjustments, but not many. And then we learned which scotch was which number. Here are my results:
For me, this time Caol Ila 12-year-old scotch was the clear winner. My son and I were both surprised how much we liked the Jura Prophecy (on the far left). It was clearly very different from the others, but we liked it.
Neither of us liked the Highland Park (second from the right) very much. After my first taste, I said, "Geez, this could be good but it has an after-taste of candy canes or something." My son agreed that it had a candy-like taste that detracted from the rest of its flavour.
Also, before we learned which scotch was which, we agreed that any but that second one from the right (Highland Park) was pretty good.
One surprise for me was that in the blind test I thought Islay Mist 8 was not as good as most of the others. Generally, I find it quite acceptable, especially for the price. I think my son's big surprise was that he ended up preferring Lagavulin, which he had not rated so highly in our previous blind taste-test.
Also we were both disappointed with the Laphroaig. That scotch had by far been my son's favourite in the past, and it just didn't taste the same at all. I wonder what happened there.
It may seem like overkill to taste-test 11 different scotches at once. It really was fine though. We made sure of two things:
- We didn't sip much during any of the taste-testing.
- We tried to carry out the taste-testing reasonably quickly so we wouldn't be too drunk before we completed the tests.
Finally, I have mixed feelings about the results of the test. In the past I have always preferred Lagavulin by a slight edge over Caol Ila and the others. I'm almost disappointed that my tastes seem to have changed a bit (though my bank account will be relieved, albeit only slightly).
I must pursue this shift in greater detail. I think doing so will require sampling more Lagavulin, Caol Ila, Jura Prophecy, Islay Mist, and Ben Riach.
p.s. All those glasses and a bunch more left over from Christmas dinner, four hours earlier:
Addendum #1: I have since tried Lagavulin and Caol Ila side-by-side. I like them both, but for the life of me, I cannot understand what happened during the blind taste test. Nevertheless, that test provided some valuable information and insight into my tastes and how variable they might be.
Addendum #2: Geez, we have a lot of scotch on hand! That's just my collection. Ms. Eclectic detests the smoky, peaty scotches, preferring Glenfiddich or Balvenie.